Last night I wrote a post here in which I pointed out the deafening silence that surrounds the recount of the Wisconsin Supreme Court Election between David Prosser and JoAnne Kloppenburg.
Tonight, I’ll elucidate why I feel that this is important, and specifically why I think that silence on this issue is ultimately damaging.
This election and it’s resulting recount are important because this was the next big step in the ongoing Wisconsin Public Union Saga that began with Governor Walker trying to pass a law that would remove collective bargaining rights from Public Employee Unions in that state.
As you all probably know, the next step was when all the Democratic State Senators left the state to forestall the vote on the measure followed by the bill’s eventual passage without the State Democratic Senators’ return, followed by the return of the State Senators, followed by the bill going to court, followed by the bill being suspended but enacted anyway, followed by the State Appeals Court sending the bill on up to the State Supreme Court, followed by the Chief Justice of that august body (Prosser) coming up for re-election, followed by the election itself which initially resulted in a win for Kloppenburg, followed by several votes being found miraculously at the last second that changed the winner to Prosser, followed by a recount, followed by yesterday’s results of said recount in which Prosser was found to in fact be the winner, followed by the afore-mentioned deafening silence.
Followed by my post in which I cranked the snark to 11 and probably (Yeah. I did that. In hindsight, I’m not too proud of it) went over the line of good taste in comparing Judge Kloppenburg’s appearance to a TV character called The Chicken Lady from The Kids In The Hall. I won’t erase anything I wrote because I hate the solution of the “Memory Hole” and I stand by my words right or wrong.
I wrote them, I own them.
However…
This silence is going to be damaging to all involved because as I pointed out last night in the comments, it is the perfect passive-aggressive means of insuring that this issue will never go away and/or be resolved satisfactorily. This will insure that in about 10 years or so, it will be “Common Knowledge” that the GOP “stole” Wisconsin.
I wanted an investigation into the very suspect and “Things-That-Make-You-Go-Hmm” circumstances that allowed for Prosser’s victory. I hope that Rob from last night’s comments can return and confirm that I did in fact sit in his living room and say the same thing the day that all those extra votes were found. He will probably even recall why I wanted an investigation:
To keep what is now happening from happening.
If we won, I want everyone to say, “The GOP won.” If we lost, I want everyone to say, “The GOP lost.” I don’t want the twin spectres of implied guilt and opacity to hover forever over this very important issue.
I want a transparent win or loss. I want everyone to acknowledge the same and then get on with life. I want that most elusive and ethereal of all Political Beasts:
The Clean Win.
I don’t think I’m going to get it though.
You see, with this matter, I now question whether or not an investigation is even necessary.
Wait…what?
Well…with the silence and the quiet acceptance and the non-making of waves over the recount’s conclusion, I wonder if everything didn’t in fact happen exactly as it was said to, improbable as that may be.
But here’s something that’s even more improbable:
That a recount conducted in a crucial election in which several Unions have a lot at stake, in which the Democratic Party has invested a lot of time, energy, and money, in which a lot of prestige and precedence is there to be won or lost, in which many Democrats were indubitably sitting in on, and presiding over, and certifying, and watching, and waiting, and observing with fine-toothed combs (to mix my metaphors) was somehow a giant sham and therefore not a valid recount.
Without any observable opposition to the conclusion of Prosser’s victory found last night on Daily Kos, a progressive and strongly Leftist website, should I conclude that there was anything amiss? If Hot Air or Big Government or Ace of Spades HQ were to report, however quietly, that we lost a major and important election, should I then conclude that they are in fact the paid-in-full servants of the Democratic Party?
Other than the Brad Blog, a site that looks to find the ultimate guilt of every major modern crime and offense to humanity exclusively in the Right Wing of American Politics, most other sites are either reporting that Prosser won or they’re ignoring the issue outright (Fire Dog Lake AND Think Progress as of last night).
What tells me that there really is nothing in the way of wrong-doing here other than the gross mishandling of votes by a former aide of Prosser, namely Ms. Kathy Nickolaus, is the fact that although whole channels of content can and have been created on YouTube to contain the sheer amount of video documentation regarding this issue from it’s beginnings to the present, although the Unions spent massive gobs of cash on defending their (up until recently) rights to collectively bargain with the State Government, although a lot of prestige and political eggs were put into the basket that is Madison, Wisconsin, NO ONE IS SERIOUSLY CALLING FOR AN INVESTIGATION!!!!!
By “No One”, I mean someone involved directly with this matter like Kloppenburg or the local Democratic Party, or the Public Employee Unions. And by “Seriously”, I mean filing complaint, appealing, or otherwise continuing the due process of finding justice within the system set up to do just that.
A search on Google for “Wisconsin Recount Supreme Court” found only one article that post-dates by one the day of the recount findings (May 20th), and it included these passages:
The major issue here is not the election of JoAnn Kloppengurg to the Wisconsin Supreme Court. That is clearly a done deal for the incumbent, David Prosser. The real issue is the collective bargaining issue in Scott Walker’s so-called budget repair bill…Walker’s bill clearly diminishes the power of the public service unions who are presently the only shining star in the union firmament. If Walker succeeds in pulling their teeth, other states are poised to follow Wisconsin’s lead, potentially creating a domino effect across the nation. Since these unions are stalwart Democrat supporters, there is clearly much at stake for many players. I believe this is the real issue in the Kloppenburg election affair…The original concept was to bounce Prosser and replace him with a Dane County liberal, thus shifting the present 4-3 conservative tilt on the Supreme Court to liberal. The budget repair bill issue will likely end up before the Supreme Court, especially subsequent to a decision unfriendly to the Walker camp…
No kidding…
So with all that is at stake, there is nothing in the way of a forthcoming investigation? No in-depth look into the discovery of the miracle ballots? No vocal and public questions to be asked? Just a sullen silence that will only further serve to poison the National Dialogue?
Great. I hope there’s one on Monday…
I just wish that with all the emperical and circumstantial evidence that points to a legitimate win for Prosser and no as-yet presented evidence what-so-ever that points to anything else (if so, where is it and why is no one making it a matter of very public record?) that everyone could publically acknowledge the wins and losses here and get on with things rather than simply go for the passive-aggressive Death-By-Silence route that we are apparently going to travel down.
Oh, and by the way. To any and all who say, “Why should we investigate? We know who did what. No one will take it seriously anyway. The GOP/Koch Brothers would just buy that out too, so what’s the point?”:
Shame on you.
Just go ahead and go to this website and make a big fat donation then. Do it! If it’s all just pointless and justice is that worthless to you, than just give up.
Sweet Lord in Heaven.
Fight for what you believe in or shut the hell up, but don’t just sit there and quietly plan on whispering to your children and your children’s children about these evil horrors of societal degeneration called “Republicans” who once upon a time “stole” the rights of a whole nation out from under us.
Because if you do that, then when those same children ask if you were in the “War”, you’ll have to avoid their eyes, say “No”, and admit that you cowered under the nearest eco-sustainable compost pile.
The results get certified on Monday, May the 23rd and then Kloppenburg will get 5 days to appeal.
I guess we’ll see then how much the Left really believes that this is a faulty, flawed, and/or felonious recount effort…
Update:
From Sierra Nolan Dely via Twitter:
State &fed investigations have been requested: according to Rep. Baldwin & AG Holder offices investigation requests will not be addressed until Klopp. legal time frame to file court challenge expired (5 days after GAB certifies recount winner)
“Rob” in the comments sends along this link from Daily Kos. It covers, as he says, a lot of what could/will happen next.
My thanks to everyone who’s been so helpful in fleshing out this story! Any other updates of worth will be posted and promoted on Twitter as usual.